Mon to Fri, 8:30a through 5:30p PST [?]
Member LoginMember Login

Hey Naomi Klein. You’re Wrong!

Posted by: Mitch Rofsky @ Oct. 20, 2014, 2:49 p.m.

OK, You’re Not That Wrong—It’s Just the Title of Your New Book…

Well-known progressive author, Naomi Klein, has just released her latest book: This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. the Climate.

Klein says that we can’t have a free market because its incentives will never stop business from destroying the climate. She calls this free market: capitalism.

But she doesn’t call for socialism.

Hmm…she hasn’t come up with a name for an economy that is between capitalism and socialism?

Here’s one:  “liberalism”—which represents regulated or mixed capitalism, not free market capitalism. But it’s still capitalism.

The fact is, liberals aren’t socialists—and shouldn’t be. Here’s why:

Socialism means government ownership—and government will never innovate like the private sector.  Even if it comes up with the innovations (which it certainly won’t in every case), it will often sit on them for fear of what it will do to existing jobs. We need innovation to increase everyone’s well being. Otherwise, it’s going to be a race between today’s Western middle class and the the world’s poor.  

Much of Klein’s effort is around framing—structuring climate change as more of an economic issue than an environmental issue.  This is effective—and special as conservatives have done a much more masterful job of framing than liberals.

But, in the U.S., the key frame isn’t around capitalism. It’s around our government, really about our history. Because to conservatives it’s all about the individual vs. the government.  

But that’s just wrong. The key frame for any country is really the marketplace vs. the government.

And the fact is: both are imperfect…and we need each to fix (or at least improve) the other.

Conservatives refuse to acknowledge the imperfections of the marketplace. Klein has focused on one of the more obvious ones: business can impose their pollution (in this case, carbon) on innocent third parties without internalizing their costs.

Only the government can fix this.

But it hasn’t.

Thus, the need for a carbon tax to price and internalize the climate change costs—and other externalities (i.e. oil spill clean-up).  As a result, fossil fuels would more accurately reflect their true costs (assuming no tax subsidies). Then alternative energy could compete without receiving subsidies as well.

Admittedly, framing is much harder for liberals than conservatives. Conservatives just need to criticize the government and promote the marketplace.  Liberals need to defend and criticize the government and the marketplace.

So Naomi, you’re doing a much better job of framing than your fellow progressives. But we still need an adjustment in your title. Perhaps: This Changes Everything: Free-Market Capitalism vs. the Climate. Or: This Changes Everything: Free-Market Capitalism vs. Regulated, More Perfect Capitalism.

You choose.


Quotes From Members

  • "Also, I'm really pleased that I found Better World; it really suits the values of my family and, by the way, my congregation and my grad students. I don't know how many in either group belong to any auto club or travel club, but they surely would be ashamed not to join up with BW if they ever join any. :)"
  • "Thanks again for your prompt and courteous and helpful support."
  • "This claim was the only time so far that we've needed to use our BWC coverage, but it was exactly what we needed in that situation, so we'll definitely keep our memberships active in case we run into issues on future rides!"
  • "You serve your market with intelligence and humor. I didn't feel like I was a family member when I had AAA, but I feel like an important part of a socially-conscious family with you. Keep the newsletters coming."
  • "Thanks very much! I switched to BWC because I believe you share my values and concern for sustainability. The hybrid discount is a great added bonus. It's great to see businesses thrive on a positive progressive message."
  • "My alternator gave out suddenly one night. I was stranded on a frontage road near the freeway, in the dark, in the rain, a couple hundred miles from home late on a weekend night. When I called BWC, your representative asked if I was in a safe place, dispatched a tow truck, and asked if I needed help finding a hotel for the night. Needless to say, I was impressed. It's good to know folks like you have my back!"
  • "Your newsletter is full of stimulating information--not only revealing the truth about companies/regulations that are unfair, unconscious, or downright despicable, but also highlighting positive efforts and developments for a better world. Really appreciate it. And also enjoy your sense of humor."
Better World Club
© 2015 Better World Club - All Rights Reserved